First competitive appearance
Brechin (Old) 1–9 Arbroath· Forfarshire Charity Cup · Montrose Street Park


Joined: 1 Jul 1892 · Left: 30 May 1896
| Manager | First appearance | Most recent appearance | Apps |
|---|---|---|---|
| Selection Committee | 31 Mar 1888 | 9 May 1896 | 38 |
· Forfarshire Charity Cup · Montrose Street Park
· Scottish Qualifying Cup · Alum Works Park
· Northern League · Balhousie Park
· Northern League · Old Gayfield
| Date | Home | Score | Away | Competition | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 9 May 1896 | Arbroath | 7–2 | Aberdeen (Old) | Northern League1895-96 | W |
| 25 Apr 1896 | Forfar | 5–2 | Arbroath | Northern League1895-96 | L |
| 4 Apr 1896 | Dundee Wands | 1–2 | Arbroath | Northern League1895-96 | W |
| 28 Mar 1896 | Fair City | 2–4 | Arbroath | Northern League1895-96 | W |
| 21 Mar 1896 | Arbroath | 3–4 | Orion | Northern League1895-96 | L |
| 14 Mar 1896 | Arbroath | 3–1 | Lochee Utd | Northern League1895-96 | W |
| 29 Feb 1896 | Arbroath | 5–0 | Dundee Wands | Northern League1895-96 | W |
| 22 Feb 1896 | Arbroath | 5–2 | Forfar | Northern League1895-96 | W |
| 15 Feb 1896 | Montrose | 3–2 | Arbroath | Northern League1895-96 | L |
| 8 Feb 1896 | Arbroath | 0–4 | Hearts | Scottish Cup1895-96 | L |
| 1 Feb 1896Neutral venue | Arbroath | 2–0 | Dundee | Forfarshire Cup1895-96 | W |
| 25 Jan 1896 | Arbroath | 3–1 | St Johnstone | Scottish Cup1895-96 | W |
| 18 Jan 1896 | Arbroath | 4–1 | Montrose | Forfarshire Cup1895-96 | W |
| 28 Dec 1895 | Dundee Harp | 1–1 | Arbroath | Forfarshire Cup1895-96 | D |
| 21 Dec 1895 | Arbroath | 1–1 | Montrose | Northern League1895-96 | D |
| 14 Dec 1895 | Dundee Harp | 2–4 | Arbroath | Forfarshire Cup1895-96 | W |
| 7 Dec 1895 | Dundee Harp | 4–2 | Arbroath | Forfarshire Cup1895-96 | L |
| 17 Nov 1894 | Arbroath | 1–2 | Dundee Wands | Forfarshire Cup1894-95 | L |
| 6 May 1893 | Arbroath | 5–1 | Johnstone Wan. | Northern League1892-93 | W |
| 29 Apr 1893 | Montrose | 2–3 | Arbroath | Northern League1892-93 | W |
| 15 Apr 1893 | Montrose | 2–1 | Arbroath | Forfarshire Charity Cup1892-93 | L |
| 8 Apr 1893 | Arbroath | 4–0 | Dundee East E | Northern League1892-93 | W |
| 1 Apr 1893 | Fair City | 2–6 | Arbroath | Northern League1892-93 | W |
| 18 Mar 1893 | Forfar | 3–3 | Arbroath | Northern League1892-93 | D |
| 11 Mar 1893 | Arbroath | 3–2 | St Johnstone | Northern League1892-93 | W |
| 11 Feb 1893 | Arbroath | 5–2 | Aberdeen (Old) | Northern League1892-93 | W |
| 28 Jan 1893Neutral venue | Arbroath | 1–0 | Dundee Harp | Forfarshire Cup1892-93 | W |
| 21 Jan 1893 | Dundee Our B | 3–2 | Arbroath | Northern League1892-93 | L |
| 17 Dec 1892 | Johnstone Wan. | 2–8 | Arbroath | Forfarshire Cup1892-93 | W |
| 3 Dec 1892 | Arbroath | 4–1 | Forfar | Northern League1892-93 | W |
| Date | Home | Score | Away | Competition | Result | Minute |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 28 Mar 1896 | Fair City | 2–4 | Arbroath | Northern League1895-96 | W | ? |
| 21 Mar 1896 | Arbroath | 3–4 | Orion | Northern League1895-96 | L | ? |
| 29 Feb 1896 | Arbroath | 5–0 | Dundee Wands | Northern League1895-96 | W | 24′ |
| 22 Feb 1896 | Arbroath | 5–2 | Forfar | Northern League1895-96 | W | ? |
| 22 Feb 1896 | Arbroath | 5–2 | Forfar | Northern League1895-96 | W | ? |
| 25 Jan 1896 | Arbroath | 3–1 | St Johnstone | Scottish Cup1895-96 | W | 89′ |
| 18 Jan 1896 | Arbroath | 4–1 | Montrose | Forfarshire Cup1895-96 | W | 65′ |
| 18 Jan 1896 | Arbroath | 4–1 | Montrose | Forfarshire Cup1895-96 | W | 88′ |
| 29 Apr 1893 | Montrose | 2–3 | Arbroath | Northern League1892-93 | W | ? |
| 8 Apr 1893 | Arbroath | 4–0 | Dundee East E | Northern League1892-93 | W | ? |
| 3 Dec 1892 | Arbroath | 4–1 | Forfar | Northern League1892-93 | W | ? |
| 19 Nov 1892 | Arbroath | 4–3 | Montrose | Forfarshire Cup1892-93 | W | ? |
| 12 Nov 1892 | Arbroath | 6–0 | Dundee Our B | Northern League1892-93 | W | ? |
| 12 Nov 1892 | Arbroath | 6–0 | Dundee Our B | Northern League1892-93 | W | ? |
| 5 Nov 1892 | Campsie | 6–3 | Arbroath | Scottish Qualifying Cup1892-93 | L | ? |