ARBROATHARCHIVEArbroath FC History
Scottish Cup · Third Round Replay

Motherwell2–0Arbroath

Don Goodman 13′
Lee McCulloch 61′
19 Feb 2000Saturday, 19 February 2000 · 3pmFir ParkAttendance: 5,311

Lineups

Motherwell

Motherwell · Starting XI

  • Andy Goram
  • Greig Denham
  • Steve McMillan
  • Michel Doesburg
  • Lee McCulloch
  • Jamie McGowan
  • Simo Valakari
  • John Spencer
  • Ged Brannan
  • John Davies
  • Don Goodman

Motherwell · Substitutes

  • Derek Townsley
  • Kevin Twaddle
  • Stevie Nicholas

Motherwell · Substitutions

  • Kevin Twaddle for Don Goodman63′
  • Derek Townsley for John Davies73′
  • Stevie Nicholas for John Spencer81′

Motherwell · Manager

  • Billy Davies

Motherwell · Cautions

  • Not recorded

Match report

The saga continues, first the wind, then a 1-1 draw at Gayfield initiates an attempt to play the replay at the Motherwell paddy field. Three attempts have been washed out (one Motherwell fan even said that the pitch conditions were nothing to do with Motherwell but due to the rain - is his the first season which it has rained in Motherwell one asks?). The Celtic saga also continues with Wight and Gould on their ways out of Parkhead and possibly Viduka too. News also surfaced during the week that Celtic had set the prices for the Scottish 4th Round…Read moreRead less
The saga continues, first the wind, then a 1-1 draw at Gayfield initiates an attempt to play the replay at the Motherwell paddy field. Three attempts have been washed out (one Motherwell fan even said that the pitch conditions were nothing to do with Motherwell but due to the rain - is his the first season which it has rained in Motherwell one asks?).

The Celtic saga also continues with Wight and Gould on their ways out of Parkhead and possibly Viduka too. News also surfaced during the week that Celtic had set the prices for the Scottish 4th Round match against Aberdeen and debited fans accounts prior to getting knocked out of the third round at home by Inverness Caledonian Thistle.

Having spent Friday night aft a family do in Inverness it was down the A9 towards Motherwell., checking the radio for confirmation that the Fir Park rice crop had been harvested and the pitch dried out. The snow at Aviemore soon gave way to fin blue skies and the temperature rose from 2 to 9 degrees. Dave Baikie's player availability problems, according to the press, do not appear to have eased since midweek with Florence and Arbuckle still unavailable as they are suspended for the replay and this is the fourth attempt which they have tried to serve their suspension. There are still injury doubts over Tindal, Crawford, Mercer and Thomson. I met up with the traveling Arbroath fans in a local Pub - Duke of Richmond or similar name - where a function room had been reserved for the visitors many of whom were making their second visit to Motherwell this week after the farcical situation on Tuesday night. The news from the fans that the Club's Sportsman dinner had gone well on the Friday night and on the player front that Tindal was out with a kidney infection.

Heading to the ground we passed the home fans gates where the price was a reasonable £12 for entry to a match featuring a Premier League Club and a Second Division Club. After a walk in the country (or so it seemed) we arrived at the away support section of the ground where, none too happy, we noticed that the prices had also been altered - from the normal Premier League price of £15 to £17.

The Police on duty outside the ground expressed their agreement that the situation was diabolical but there was nothing the could do about it along with the people on the gates who got dogs abuse about the way we were being treated. The money grabbing attitude by John Boyle and his Motherwell Club against the Arbroath fans took the fans minds away from the imminent match as they fumed about the inconsistent pricing. It appears that the Motherwell fans n the main stand were also paying the increased price of £17 but at least they had the choice of paying £12 or £17- we should have taken off our colours and gone into the £12 section.

Back to the game in hand after getting the above off my chest and Dave Baikie had made a surprise selection of young Andrew Webster in a defensive midfield position. The young under 18 player was making his third first team appearance of the season with the Stirling Albion Challenge Cup match and the early season league defeat at Ross County being his other two. The got us talking about why Dave Baikie does not introduce the youngsters earlier into the team rather than waiting for necessity. We lined up with Wight, Peters, Gallagher, McAulay, Thomson, Webster, Cooper, Bryce, McGlashan, Sellars and Mercer. On the bench were Crawford, Devine and Brownlie.

We kicked off the first half attacking Andy Goram's goal which was the one in front of our £17 stand ( having paid all this money we were treated to a tannoy system which was even worse than the old Gayfield system - blaring out from behind us we could not make out a word). Motherwell, as expected started off as if they were going to finish us off quickly but after weathering the first waves off attack we gradually got into the game and were looking a good match for our Premier League opponents. Encouraged by our start the away support was vocally supporting their team with a melody of songs targeted at Andy Goram, the home fans, Montrose and Aberdeen. Tommy Bryce had a great chance when he met a Cooper cross but alas, with the goal at his mercy, the ball bounced aff his baldie bit and went over the bar. Like last week's match at Ross County, just as we were getting things together we lost a sucker goal after 13 minutes when Don Goodman picked up the ball from a 1-2 and, unmarked, shot home past the helpless Wight. Poetic justice that he scored, I thought, as this should shut up the few moronic raciest boo-boys in our support - alas it did not. Motherwell pushed forward looking to kill the game of now but our defence held out and despite being up against it we did have a few chances to bring us back into the game. Our efforts were not assisted by McCurry (the referee) who appeared to be favouring the home team with some strange decisions. McGlashan had a shot at Goram's goals but alas did not connect right and his poor effort was easily collected, Bryce had a good run down the left but with Sellars lying free to his right he elected to try to beat the defender and lost the ball. Cooper was booked for a tussle on the left, Sellars broke through the centre and with only a defender between him and the goal elected to pass to Cooper who was supporting him however the pass was not ideal (I thought that Coops had chickened out a bit) and another chance to get back into the game was lost. McGlashan went down in the penalty box appearing to have been hit in the goullies but play continued. The referee missed a Motherwell hand ball in midfield and hen allowed play to continue when Sellars was brutally tripped in midfield, Webster did similar to win the ball back and was booked for his effort as was McAulay who expressed disgust about the official's lack of consistency. In the last minute Sellars broke free and his good shot was deflected by Goram's foot for a corner - had we got the break here it might have been a different second half. In the meantime Motherwell had had a few opportunities to increase their lead but failed to take them and did not look like a team that was third top of the Premier league.

At half-time the discussions over the ticket prices continued and in reality we did not feel that we would make the next round.

There were no changes at half-time despite our 75 year-old joint striking force looking a bit slow and therefore not really tormenting the home defence. Some of the fans would have liked to have seen Brownlie or Devine on for Bryce to give us a bit more mobility up front but alas this was not so. Our defence were soaking up the home pressure then disaster struck as McAulay and Thomson decided to pratt around with the ball instead of clearing upfield. The result of this was that Thomson's short pass was intercepted and the ball broke to a Motherwell forward who kindly accepted the ball and slotted it past Wight to put Motherwell home and dry after 62 minutes. At the other end we had a couple of chances with Mercer doing well but alas his shot went wide of Goram's right hand post. McGlashan had a shot but again failed to connect properly and it caused Goram no problems. We got a god view of Motherwell's attack this half and their huffing and puffing attempts resulted in the ball hitting our crossbar once and the post twice along with a number of feeble efforts - one shot never even managed to go out of play stopping dead near the corner post. Cooper was replaced by Brownlie after 70 minutes and six minutes later Devine replaced Bryce whose auld legs were not up to the rigours of playing against a full-time Premier League Club. There was no more scoring and the Motherwell fans, like Rangers fans, started exiting their seats with 10 minutes to go.

We did not disgrace ourselves against the 3rd best team in Scotland (shows you the state of Scottish Football) and had Sellar's effort gone in just before half-time things might have been different. There were no failures in the team with Sellars and Mercer looking every bit as good as their midfield Premier League opponents. Young Webster found the going tough but was not shown up against the Premier League outfit and hopefully will get the opportunity to stake his place in the first team along with the likes of Steele and Wares who were both warming up with the team to soak in the atmosphere. Our future must revolve around the youth - let's give them a chance now and concentrate on consolidating our Second Division position. Thankfully we can now get back to decent priced matches and not mugged as we were today by John Boyle's Motherwell

arbroathfc.org.uk

Match programme cover