Scottish League · First Division
Arbroath1–1St Mirren
Andy Dow 52′
Mark Roberts 4′
Lineups
Arbroath
Arbroath · Starting XI
Arbroath · Substitutes
Arbroath · Substitutions
- Darren Spink for Eddie Forrest13′
- Andy Cargill for Ross Currie72′
- Paul Brownlie for Gavin Swankie72′
Arbroath · Manager
Arbroath · Cautions
St Mirren
St Mirren · Starting XI
- Ludovic Roy
- Jamie McGowan
- Martin Baker
- Kirk Broadfoot
- Greig Denham
- Jamie Dunbar
- Hugh Murray
- Paul McHale
- Simon Lappin
- Ricky Gillies
- Mark Roberts
St Mirren · Substitutes
- Kris Robertson
- Chris Kerr
- Graham Guy
- David Lowing
- Jeff Ferguson
St Mirren · Substitutions
- David Lowing for Martin Baker48′
- Jeff Ferguson for Jamie Dunbar81′
St Mirren · Manager
- John Coughlin
St Mirren · Cautions
- Hugh Murray48′
- Greig Denham70′
Match report
Today’s weather was the classic advert for summer football, out of the strong wind it was a glorious day. However, the lunchtime start seemed to catch out our favourites as within four minutes St Mirren had scored. McMullen’s clearance was directly to a St. Mirren player and a couple of swift passes and Mark Roberts sidefooted the ball into the net. Hinchcliffe was in goal; McMullen was at right back, Florence at left. The central defence started as Ritchie and Forrest, but Eddie really wasn’t fit and was withdrawn for Spink as early as the twelfth minute. The defence had…Read moreRead less
Today’s weather was the classic advert for summer football, out of the strong wind it was a glorious day. However, the lunchtime start seemed to catch out our favourites as within four minutes St Mirren had scored. McMullen’s clearance was directly to a St. Mirren player and a couple of swift passes and Mark Roberts sidefooted the ball into the net. Hinchcliffe was in goal; McMullen was at right back, Florence at left. The central defence started as Ritchie and Forrest, but Eddie really wasn’t fit and was withdrawn for Spink as early as the twelfth minute. The defence had been at sixes and sevens before Darren’s entry, he provided solidity, but clearly his confidence was not what it was and he needed guiding through the game by Ritchie. Andy Dow started in central midfield and he had our first real chance, his free kick was rocketed in at Roy in goal, who spilled the ball but two attempts at the rebound failed to produce a finish. Dow flitted between the centre and left as Bowman went between there and upfront, he was to have another poor game, two headers from corners put over the bar were his only plus points. Otherwise he was a makeweight. Currie played in the centre midfield where he was at sometime joined by Henslee, when Heenan moved from his forward position to right wing. Gavin Swankie started again at striker. The bench consisted of Brownlie, Woodcock, Cargill and McAuley. Most of our good play was up the right as the strong wind from the Switchie end was blowing towards the stand.
The wind was making it difficult for the defenders to get any purchase on the ball and with St Mirren happy to defend their lead there was little incident. With refereeing students in the stand Rowbotham gave a masterclass in the finer arts of how to be a Scottish referee, ie ineptitude, you could tell he was disappointed Rangers weren’t playing so he could give a penalty, perhaps Ross Currie could have mentioned he used to be there. His best decision was slow in execution, whistling very late for an offside that gave St Mirren a second goal.
The second half saw no change in personnel, but with the wind behind us we switched to a 4 3 3 with Bowman as centre forward. It was McMullen that started the move for the equaliser, his mazy dribble saw him tackled in the box, Roy’s clearance was to a maroon shirt, a quick pass down the inside right channel and the cutback bypassed the keeper to a grateful down to sidefoot home. His own personal delight to score against his former employers was writ large on his face.
But as ever Hinchcliffe had a lion’s share of the work defensively and a great double save kept us afloat. Dow was exerting pressure down the left with Swankie; Andy’s free kick was headed weakly into Roy’s hands. A Roy pass to his Broadfoot saw the defender totally miscontrol the ball for a throw in, this set up an attack from which Dow was unfortunate with his penalty claim.
With twenty minutes left Currie was replaced by Cargill and for some reason Swankie was taken off for Brownlie and the ineffectual Bowman stayed on. Andy looked ring rusty but showed some good touches, opening the defence particularly on the left. Baby was part of an attack that huffed and puffed and whose biggest threat was Heenan who was beating the left back every time he got the ball. However, we still required McMullen’s commitment with a last ditch tackle as Roberts was poised to shoot.
The game fizzled out and was nothing special in the end, but at least we got a point. Cusick will be back for next week, Cargill hopefully fitter and so the midfield will be stronger, however Forrest looks out for a few weeks more.
Ratings Hinchcliffe 8, McMullen 7, Ritchie 7, Forrest 3, Spink 6, Florence 6, Dow 8, Currie 7, Henslee 6, Heenan 7, Swankie 6, Bowman 2, Cargill 5, Brownlie 4
The wind was making it difficult for the defenders to get any purchase on the ball and with St Mirren happy to defend their lead there was little incident. With refereeing students in the stand Rowbotham gave a masterclass in the finer arts of how to be a Scottish referee, ie ineptitude, you could tell he was disappointed Rangers weren’t playing so he could give a penalty, perhaps Ross Currie could have mentioned he used to be there. His best decision was slow in execution, whistling very late for an offside that gave St Mirren a second goal.
The second half saw no change in personnel, but with the wind behind us we switched to a 4 3 3 with Bowman as centre forward. It was McMullen that started the move for the equaliser, his mazy dribble saw him tackled in the box, Roy’s clearance was to a maroon shirt, a quick pass down the inside right channel and the cutback bypassed the keeper to a grateful down to sidefoot home. His own personal delight to score against his former employers was writ large on his face.
But as ever Hinchcliffe had a lion’s share of the work defensively and a great double save kept us afloat. Dow was exerting pressure down the left with Swankie; Andy’s free kick was headed weakly into Roy’s hands. A Roy pass to his Broadfoot saw the defender totally miscontrol the ball for a throw in, this set up an attack from which Dow was unfortunate with his penalty claim.
With twenty minutes left Currie was replaced by Cargill and for some reason Swankie was taken off for Brownlie and the ineffectual Bowman stayed on. Andy looked ring rusty but showed some good touches, opening the defence particularly on the left. Baby was part of an attack that huffed and puffed and whose biggest threat was Heenan who was beating the left back every time he got the ball. However, we still required McMullen’s commitment with a last ditch tackle as Roberts was poised to shoot.
The game fizzled out and was nothing special in the end, but at least we got a point. Cusick will be back for next week, Cargill hopefully fitter and so the midfield will be stronger, however Forrest looks out for a few weeks more.
Ratings Hinchcliffe 8, McMullen 7, Ritchie 7, Forrest 3, Spink 6, Florence 6, Dow 8, Currie 7, Henslee 6, Heenan 7, Swankie 6, Bowman 2, Cargill 5, Brownlie 4
arbroathfc.org.uk