ARBROATHARCHIVEArbroath FC History
Scottish League · First Division

Arbroath1–1Ayr Utd

Murray McDowell (pen.) 72′
Eddie Annand 16′
5 Nov 2002Tuesday, 5 November 2002 · 7:30pmGayfieldAttendance: 381

Lineups

Ayr Utd

Ayr Utd · Starting XI

  • Craig Nelson
  • Willie Lyle
  • Paul Lovering
  • Marc Smyth
  • Allan McManus
  • David Craig
  • Scott Chaplain
  • Iain Nicolson
  • Eddie Annand
  • James Grady
  • Paul Sheerin

Ayr Utd · Substitutes

  • John Dodds
  • Stewart Kean
  • Mark McColl
  • Mick Dunlop
  • Aaron Black

Ayr Utd · Substitutions

  • Mick Dunlop for Eddie Annand83′
  • Aaron Black for Willie Lyle86′

Ayr Utd · Manager

  • Gordon Dalziel

Ayr Utd · Cautions

  • Paul Sheerin32′
  • Paul Sheerin77′
  • Willie Lyle79′

Ayr Utd · Red cards

  • Paul Sheerin77′
  • Marc Smyth81′

Match report

Putting on a hurriedly rearranged fixture on a Tuesday night was always going to produce a low crowd, putting it against Bonfire Night and Return of the Jedi on TV made this crowd tiny. Innes Ritchie was feeling the effects of a cold and didn’t make the sixteen, so Craig Hinchcliffe lead out the team, which played in a 5-3-2 formation. Tait was on the right and Bowman on the left, the central three in defence was Spink, Browne and Florence. Midfield saw the return of Cargill alongside McGlashan and McAulay, with Heenan and Feroz up front. The first half…Read moreRead less
Putting on a hurriedly rearranged fixture on a Tuesday night was always going to produce a low crowd, putting it against Bonfire Night and Return of the Jedi on TV made this crowd tiny. Innes Ritchie was feeling the effects of a cold and didn’t make the sixteen, so Craig Hinchcliffe lead out the team, which played in a 5-3-2 formation. Tait was on the right and Bowman on the left, the central three in defence was Spink, Browne and Florence. Midfield saw the return of Cargill alongside McGlashan and McAulay, with Heenan and Feroz up front.

The first half had the pace of a training game; the defence looked good, particularly Spink who resembled Andy Webster at his best. Kevin Heenan started brightly, a mazy run failed to produce a shot, but he and Feroz drifted out of the game as the half wore on and they saw less and less of the ball. Craig had a snapshot drift wide, and that was our only shot of the half. Our first warning about defensive lapses came when Hinchcliffe had to race out of his box to head clear, the return went wide of goal, but the disaster was to strike after quarter of an hour. An innocuous lobbed ball caused confusion between Florence and Hinchcliffe and Eddie Annand pounced to stick the ball between the goalie’s legs and it barely rolled over the line. Andy Cargill and John McGlashan rose to the challenge, Andy twisted and turned through midfield and won a freekick, Bowman’s ball was flighted over the Ayr defence and Nelson would have been stranded if McGlashan had got a touch. Little did we know that it would be our last decision for 30 minutes. McGlashan and Cargill were both booked, whilst it appeared the Honest Men were getting away with murder. We made some pressure Spink heading over from one of several corners. Cargill was karate kicked and Bowman clotheslined but still no award from the referee. We had a lucky escape as Jordan twice cleared the ball off the line from a corner and in the dying seconds of the half a wickedly dipping shot hit the crossbar.

The half time score could easily have 3-1 against. Even with a tiny crowd, a halftime cuppa meant my good lady missed the start of the second half. From what she told me the same number of staff were on as last Saturday. JB made a double substitution for the second half, Murray McDowell and Paul Durno replaced Feroz and Heenan and both started brightly as the AFC got tore in for a change. Murray had three attempts at goal in the first ten minutes as he tried to make me eat my words from the last game and I was more impressed by his performance tonight than at any game. Good skill from Paul Durno on the left started a good build up until Cargill ran offside. Then Ayr started to compact the game any were gaining the upperhand. JB made his final switch with Greg Henslee coming on for the tiring Cargill and adding more grit to battled out of defence. I think Greg is the best of the young guns and should be playing in every game; his ability and commitment are first class.

Then the fireworks started.... Sweet revenge came. Murray won a freekick for falling over near an Ayr player down the left. Henslee was fouled attacking Bowman’s freekick and the ref pointed to the spot. Murray sent a rocket into the net with Nelson going the wrong way. This really set alight the Arbroath team and they pushed forward roasting the Ayr defence, Greg fought to get a shot off and this determination saw him assaulted by Ayr’s number 11, he was booked for his challenge but the ref forgot that he had already booked him. His assistant pointed his error out and off the player went. Then the Ayr number four scythed Jordan and the red was pulled out straight away. We had ten minutes left and the opposition team are down to 9 men. All true and experienced Lichtophiles were in a blind panic, this was truly a recipe for disaster.

Tait was tiring and Henslee struggling a bit. However Jordan did well to control the ball in the Ayr box, but his cut back was too strong to be picked up. Paul Durno showed good ability on the left and played the ball into Murray McDowell who spun like a Catherine wheel only for the ball to bobble off his standing foot as he went to shoot. Murray then won a corner; McAulay’s shot from the clearance was deflected wide.
Then it got scary, an Ayr freekick saw a header flash wide as they kept us pinned in our own half. In the very last minute McGlashan broke free from the halfway line but instead of running past the centre half and nabbing the penalty as he brushed against him, he turned inside and into trouble, his frustration at the final whistle matched us all.
This was much better in the second half; the young players gave some experienced teammates a showing up. Sod EastEnders, Tuesday night football is much more exciting.

Ratings Hinchcliffe 6, Tait 7, Spink 8, Browne 8, Florence 6, Cargill 6, McGlashan 7, McAulay 6, Bowman 6, Feroz 6, Heenan 5, McDowell 7, Durno 6, Henslee 6

arbroathfc.org.uk

Match programme cover